Signs point to the fact that Mitt Romney took yesterday’s speech seriously. Criticized often for projecting an air critics call robotic or scripted even in informal settings, he spoke convincingly of a faith that’s shaped his heritage. His campaign says he wrote the speech himself.
But what did everyone else think? Most of the media were smitten. So were major voices on the right like Rush Limbaugh and James Dobson. The immediate reaction from speech attendees was also largely positive; press folks like pundit Glenn Beck (also a Mormon) immediately dropped words like “homerun.”
But attendees were either media or by-invitation-only guests — two of the groups least critical of Romney’s Mormonism.The former governor did “a magnificent job,” Richard Land, president of the Southern Baptist Convention’s Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, told a CNN crew. Land, who already gave Romney a few suggestions for the speech, said he personally encouraged Romney to give the speech more than a year ago.
But for the average Joes, many of whom said it did reinforce Romney’s morality, the speech didn’t necessarily sway votes, even though they mostly agreed it was good, even presidential sounding. Rabbi Peter Tarlow, of the Texas A&M Hillel Foundation, said he thought Romney “stood up for the importance of giving equal footing for all faiths in America,” though he remains undecided about who he is supporting in 2008. Scott Talbert, pastor of McDade Baptist Church in McDade, Texas, said he thought Romney “has got a real moral compass.” He added that “what he said was often right — like about how we’ve taken this idea of separation of church and state out of control,” but he’s not won over mainly because it’s hard for him not to support Mike Huckabee, a fellow Southern Baptist and former pastor.
Jenna Tomlinson*, who chairs AARP — Atheists and Agnostics for Ron Paul — at Texas A&M University, said the speech was insulting: “Short version of the speech? ‘I’m Mormon, but at least I’m not an atheist,’ ” she said. “As an atheist and a conservative who considers herself very moral, I was pretty offended that he didn’t talk about the contributions of atheists to America and their right to not believe in any god.”
Rob Sivulka, president of Courageous Christians United, is part of the reason why his campaign thought Romney needed to give the speech. Standing next to a sign that read “JOSEPH LIED” (that is, Joseph Smith), Sivulka doesn’t quibble with Romney on policy positions so much as solely contest his theological ones. But he said he wanted Romney to “come clean in his speech,” to tell everyone that “he is basically a bishop” in the LDS church. “But he didn’t,” Sivulka said, summing the speech up as “pretending like Mormons are Christians.”
* UPDATE: Atheists and Agnostics for Ron Paul, if it exists, apparently does not have a website, and the name “Jenna Tomlinson” is not in the Texas A&M student directory. WoW may have been taken for a ride.